KNOXVILLE, TN — The NorthStar Church community is grieving the heartbreaking and unexpected loss of Pastor Scott Cagle, a beloved spiritual leader, teacher, and mentor who touched countless lives through his ministry. Reports indicate that Pastor Cagle passed away suddenly in what is now described as suicide, leaving the congregation and wider Knoxville community in deep mourning.
Pastor Cagle, known for his compassionate heart, humble leadership, and unwavering dedication to sharing the message of Jesus Christ, served as founder and lead pastor of NorthStar Church. Over the years, he became a pillar of faith and hope for many, guiding members of his congregation through life’s challenges and celebrating their joys with sincerity and love.
Those who knew him best remember him not just as a pastor, but as a friend, mentor, and spiritual father. His teachings were deeply rooted in the Gospel, emphasizing grace, forgiveness, and authentic faith. Through his sermons and personal example, Pastor Cagle inspired others to seek a deeper relationship with God and to love others selflessly.
“Scott Cagle taught me so much about the Bible, about living for Jesus, and about truly knowing Him,” one church member shared. “Through Scott’s example, I learned what it means to love others for Him. My family is forever grateful for the ministry of Scott Cagle and NorthStar Church. I’m especially thankful that, on the day of my children’s baptisms, I had the chance to tell Scott ‘thank you’ — for founding NorthStar, for all that his sermons had taught me and my children about Jesus, and for the way his ministry led to their decisions to follow Jesus Christ.”
Quoting Matthew 25:23, members of the congregation have found comfort in the verse:
“Well done, my good and faithful servant.”
For many, these words capture the essence of Pastor Cagle’s life and legacy — a life devoted to serving Christ and guiding others toward faith.
Another longtime member shared, “To say Scott Cagle played a huge role in our lives would be a dramatic understatement. The fact that we chose to raise our kids at NorthStar and under his leadership for 14 years is the highest compliment I can give him and speaks to how highly we regarded him. He will be dearly missed.”
Pastor Cagle’s influence extended beyond the walls of the church. He was a familiar face in the Knoxville area, known for his outreach efforts, counseling, and commitment to building a community centered on faith, kindness, and compassion. His death has left not only his congregation but the broader faith community grappling with grief and reflection.
In the wake of his passing, NorthStar Church has opened its doors to members of the congregation and the public, offering spaces for prayer, counseling, and remembrance. Church leaders have emphasized the importance of coming together in support, especially for those struggling with feelings of loss, sadness, or confusion.
Mental health professionals and local faith leaders have also encouraged anyone facing emotional or spiritual distress to seek help and to remember that no one is ever alone in their pain. The tragedy has reignited conversations about mental health awareness in ministry, a topic that many hope will lead to greater understanding and compassion across faith communities.
As the community mourns, tributes continue to pour in — both online and in person — honoring Pastor Cagle’s memory and the countless lives he touched.
He will be remembered for his faithful service, gentle spirit, and unwavering love for God and people. His teachings and legacy will continue to live on through those he mentored, baptized, and inspired to walk with Christ.
Funeral and memorial arrangements will be announced by NorthStar Church in the coming days.
If you or someone you know is struggling with thoughts of self-harm or suicide, please reach out for help. In the U.S., you can contact the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline by dialing 988 for free, confidential support 24/7.